I’m in the (slow) process of changing all my posted video clips so that I have to approve comments before they become public. You’re thinking, “What’s the matter, can’t take negative criticism?” Actually I can take it very well, have been for years (in my music career), and I understand that I can learn from it. That statement would read better if it said “intelligent negative criticism.” If you’ve spent at least 15 minutes on YouTube reading various user comments, you know exactly what I’m talking about. Some bozo who thinks he has the definitive answer on everything will post something that is actually so misinformed, so irrelevant, so closed-minded, or so utterly stupid, that they repeatedly expose themselves as either (a) assholes, (b) idiots, or (c) both.
So, if you post something on one of my clips and it doesn’t get approved, then thank me for not allowing the rest of the world to see what a moron you are.
Here’s a few of the statements that I did not approve (edited for brevity):
“Tuning half step down hides the true tone of the amp.” This poor fellow went on the explain how Jimi Hendrix tuned to half step because he didn’t know any better and nobody back then cared about tuning, and Eddie Van Halen did it to “try and be like Hendrix.” Excuse me sir, but doesn’t the NAME of the clip indicate why I tuned down half step for the demo? (Van Halen recorded a lot of his early tracks tuned half step down)
“There’s no way Eddie could get his tone just from the amp. A 100 watt Marshall is still clean (no distortion) at full volume. He must have used a distortion pedal” And this pertains to my amp clip how? This is the kind of guy I’d like to put in front of my Superlead and a stack, crank the amp to 10, play a few AC/DC riffs, and scream “Does it still sound clean now?”
Next time someone asks me if my amps “will do the Van Halen tone” I’ll simply say “Yes, but only if Eddie is playing it!” and save myself a bunch of hassle.
In conclusion, arguing about Eddie Van Halen’s tone on the internet is like running a race in the special olympics. Even if you win, you’re still retarded.